Home >> Arts >> Literature >> Myths and Folktales >> Myths >> Comparative Mythology




Comparative mythology, related to comparative religion, is a field of survey which is technically a portion of anthropology but more commonly regarded when section of the subject of ancient history. A field tries to discover how else various myths and religions evolved over period, & aims to reveal relationships between distant religions, & describe their origin. Of these super easily-known recent creator therein field was Joseph Campbell. Numerous of its discoveries elicit peachy curiosity, like Poseidon having pre-dated the conception of the Olympians, and originally getting been the land-depending god.

Theories in the field have a tendency to denigrate historicity of events claimed to use occurred by religions & indicate that since a idea of what is considered per faiths when confessedly has evolved bit by bit, no particular cause to trust a recent ideas across a older ones. Developments therein field come typically think of extremely controversial while it require modern faiths, like Christianity and Hinduism, because they are seen when undermining claims of historical truth one dogma of faith.

By using sooner religions there exists tremendously less disputation & consequently very much other constructive search occurs. One of a virtually all successful developments has been a unfair theoretical reconstruction of Proto-Indo-European religion, which was informed by work in the field of Proto-Indo-European language. Survey of early religion of this sort is heavy attached to comparative linguistics, because the apparently distinct behaviour of gods & more numbers makes it hard to draw identifications forgoing sorting through linguistic modems.

Despite its significance, a field of learn, rather ancient history as a whole, has few faculty member in comparison more areas of the food and drug administration. Inside effect, developments come slow & drawn-out & ofttimes suffer uncontested ridicule at a mitts of religious conservativist & scholars around more fields whose theories might otherwise become damaged. This situation is non aided per limited total of more academician in the field to read & constructively criticise such locate when it develops.

One of a number one modern titles in the field was The Two Babylons, which unfortunately is supplementary the polemic against Roman Catholicism than academic text, & numerous of its theories own since been overturned by subsequent the food and drug administration and read. An additional early modern title was The White Goddess, in which tries were mass produced to bring together several goddesses from either various classical cultures, claiming it developed from one shared out figure.

Tremendously of the early function has since been firmly disregarded, part due to the discoveries of comparative linguistics, indicating tremendously additional plausible relationships (like that of the Norns). A second understanding for disregarding a babies has been the construction of better & further gradual evolution of gods & characters mentioned. Nonetheless, although these are tempting to totally forget about numbers of one theories, these are crucial to note that these are single virtually all of the works that keep around been thrown away, whereas little area of the texts own been supported by late, & supplementary faculty member, the food and drug administration.

Fields of study
Comparing Eastern and Western religious traditions Fundamentalism Creation myth Christianity and Buddhism Judeo-Christian Comparing and contrasting Judaism and Christianity Christo-Islamic Development of religion

Myths and Myth-makers: Old Tales and Superstitions Interpreted by Comparative Mythology
By John Fiske (1900), e-tetxt from the Electronic Text Center, University of Virginia Library.

Greek Mythology Compared to Norse Mythology
Essay by Gareth Long comparing the main Greek and Norse gods.

Myth of Creation
Articles on mythology by Stefan Stenudd, working on a dissertation on creation myths and their patterns of thought.

The Golden Bough
Classical work by Sir James George Frazer, from the 1922 edition.

Max Müller's Comparative Mythology (1856)
Excerpted from Max Müller's "Chips From a German Workshop."

The Anthropology of Mythology
Dedicated to the on-going study of world mythology and how humankind uses myth to express its belief in God.

Mythopedia
Proposing a theory of unity of human mythology, listing the common motifs in mythology, ritual, and symbolism, with comprehensive encyclopaedia of gods and myths from all corners of the world.

The Architecture of the Spirit
Online book by Pete Stewart, exploring the suggestion that the myth of creation derives from observation of the stars, and is reflected in social and spiritual structures.

Common Elements in Creation Myths
Explores and highlights commonalities amongst stories depicting the creation of the world from several cultures.

Georges Dumézil - Indo-European Mythology
Discussion group for the work of Georges Dumézil on Indo-European mythology and trifunctionality.






© 2005 GeneralAnswers.org